More on languages
I loved all the comments yesterday about God's remarkable vocabulary and the remarkableness of Godwriting™. If you haven't read the comments yet, you have a treat in store for you.
Language is a non-ending topic of fascination for me. It certainly is a miracle that we move our lips, synchronized with our tongues, vocal chords, mind and it is another miracle that other people also speak and understand these sounds. How did we ever learn to do this? How much we want to speak. It must be a basic need. How much we want to communicate.
I suspect that with language, as with Godwriting, there are underlying sounds from God, from nature, from which all languages arise. It must be that language starts in the same place, and then, like flowers, languages bloom in infinite varieties.
And, as time goes on, new idioms arise in every language, and some of the old expressions fall off, and some words in a language come to have different meanings from what they used to. Language is not a stationary thing, not at all, unless it becomes a language that people no longer speak. And how does that happen? What happened that Latin became a dead language?
I remember that, at the time I was teaching school, there were only three or four living persons who spoke the Hopi language. In that case, all the speakers but three or four had died. I am so sad.
So far as I know, the only dead language that ever came back to life, is Hebrew. Hebrew was chosen over Yiddish as the language of Israel. The idea must have been that Hebrew had a great heritage and would be respected. But how is it that Hebrew had died in the first place?
I also remember from my school-teaching days that there are, of course, families of languages. There are languages that seem to be all by themselves. None of the scholars knew where certain languages came from. The examples I remember are Basque and Japanese.
I read recently that in Cameroon, a country in Africa, the people speak 250 dialects!
In regard to the idea that all languages started from one level of sound, I'm sure I told you that one time Effendi from the Sufi House spoke to me in Turkish, and, to both our amazement, I understood what Effendi had said. We exchanged a few sentences before we were aware of what was happening.
My sudden realization that Effendi was talking to me in Turkish and I was understanding Turkish broke my understanding. I couldn't even remember what I had understood a few moments before. You have to know that Effendi wasn't saying, "Here, have a piece of cake," something that anyone would understand. He was saying something pertinent to my life.
But at the same time, apparently, he wasn't saying it for me to understand, for when I asked him what he had said, he wouldn't tell me. It wasn't for me to know. I sure do want to know what he had said. I think it was something wonderful, and I think I will never know -- how would he remember now?
There are so many things I will never know!
Comments
You say "there are so many things I will never know", but a part of you DOES know them. It's just blocked to the human mind, but not to the God mind. I myself wish I knew what I said to my beloved as he lay dying in hospital and I cradled his head and stroked his cheek, but I was in a "higher state" and my human mind memory made no record of it. Yet I know that when I pass "onward and upward", those words will be known to me then. Nothing is ever lost.
In South Africa there are ~11 official languages and many many dialects. There are unofficial languages, one of which is called funagalo. Funagalo is a mix of several languages and came about from the communication between mine supervisors and miners from different tribal groups.
I enjoy looking at words form different languages and having fun with them...
In Spanish is dolor is pain. Isn't it similar to dollar?
Peso is the currency in many Latin American countries. Peso means heavy or weight. Lot's of pesos might be a heavy burden to carry!
aDios is a common way to say goodbye in Spanish, but what we're really saying is, "go with God".
Interestingly many folk use the expression "te quiero", to say I love you. Te quiero, directly translated, means I want you. "Te amo", means I love you.
Como se llama? is usually used to ask what is your name - directly translated, it means What are you called which is just beautiful! It's so unattached and by the way, like we are not in possession of the name.
The Tower of Babel
The topic of language is endless. Linguistics have taught us a lot about the structure and evolution of languages in the relative world. There are two major things (in fact there are many more major things) to consider.
1) the formation of comprehensible words as organized sounds needs vowels and stops where vowels are a continuous shaped flow of air and consonants which block the air flow like the keys on a wind musical instrument. And there are less consonants than we think of if we consider that a "p" and a "b" are the same consonants, "p" being a mute or soundless stop while "b" is the same consonant but with voicing. The same goes with f/v. t/d, k/g, etc.
2) There is the arbitrary nature of the linguistic sign, which means that there is no natural, ontological or physical relation between a word and its meaning. The word "table" has nothing to do with the physical entity of the table. The proof of that fact is that spanish will use the word "mesa" and german will use "Tisch".
The science of linguistics, though, cannot say much about the real origin of language. It has not discovered the linguistic Big Bang. And, in fact, even the Big Bang does not explain the origin of the world as we perceive it through science.
Did the split between the word as a sign and the thing that it refers to happen with the invention of ego? The Tower of Babel might be an insight.
I think we need more of God's Knowledge in the understanding of language. There must have been a "time" where the word (as a combination of sound and light) was the thing it meant to create. But "at that time" it was not a human language but an angelic one and the language was One, without any kind of dialects.